Why Is Offside a Rule

Going back to the original question; The offside rule makes sense, although very loaded and a bit difficult to understand. It basically says;. To score a fair goal, you have to work hard, run faster or outsmart your opponent, being in an advantageous place (being lazy or obviously lucky) is not “sporty” (not sure if this word exists in English). Above all, if a defender enters because he feels he would force an attacker into an offside position, it is no longer enough to make him active. This means that against savvy opponents who manage to keep the ball away from those who ran offside, the offside trap has become ineffective. In 1866, the law was liberalized so that a player was considered offside if there were three defensive players between him and the goal (or behind the ball, which remained a constant); This was the variant Queen`s Park had committed to when they joined the FA four years later. In 1873, this law was amended to judge offside when the ball was played, not when the player received the ball. Sometimes referees miss a scorer from an offside position or drop a truly deserved goal, usually followed by a group of weeping football fans in the stands. A player is in an offside position if he (part of the head, feet or body) is closer to the opponent`s goal line than the penultimate defender and the ball – and he is in the opposing half of the pitch in accordance with Act 11 of the FIFA Rules. A player is in an offside position when he is in the opponent`s half of the field and is also “closer to the opponent`s goal line than the ball and the penultimate opponent”. [1] The 2005 edition of the Rules of the Game included a new IFAB decision stating: “In defining offside, `closer to the opponent`s goal line` means that any part of the opponent`s head, body or feet is closer to the opponent`s goal line than the ball and the penultimate opponent.

Coats of arms are not included in this definition. [6] Until 2017, the wording was changed to indicate that when assessing offside position, “the hands and arms of all players, including goalkeepers, are not taken into account.” [1] In other words, a player is in an offside position when two conditions are met: one of the main tasks of assistant referees is to assist the referee in assessing offside[3] – their position on the sideline allows for a more useful lateral view across the field. Assistant referees communicate that an offside offence has occurred by raising a signal flag. [4]: 191 However, as with all official decisions of the game, it is ultimately up to the referee, who can override the advice of his assistants if he deems it appropriate. [5] First introduced in 1883 when the Football Association (FA) formalised the rules of football, offside was built to prevent players from always hiding near the opponent`s goal looking for scoring opportunities. (a) Disturbance of play Touch the ball with any part of your body when you are in an offside position. The laws of football have always allowed you to commit an offside offence from a free kick. The free kick is in contrast to other game restarts such as penalty shootout, corner kick and throw.

Here, the offside rule is explained in 3 simple points. Although the offside variant of the FA was based on a dribbling game when it was introduced in 1863, the variants further north – for example in Nottingham, Derby, Sheffield and Scotland – where a passing game prevailed, were designed to stop the suspended goal and prevent the game from becoming endless hooves in the danger zone, where a goalkeeper was fighting with a handful of attackers. who could legitimately stand right in front of him. All of us who have played and love the sport known as football in the United States have reservations about the offside rule. Many have advocated for it to be eliminated completely. Those who are in favour of keeping the rule intact use the “poaching” argument, which is valid to some extent. But there is no need to eliminate the rule. An amendment is all that is needed. Instead of shouting offside every time an attacker`s tip of the foot is in front of the penultimate defender, the rule should only be enforced if the entire body of the attacking player is clearly and unambiguously in front of the penultimate defender. This takes care of poaching. In addition, the rule should not be invoked if the whole game is inside the box, because by definition there is no poaching and the defense has had every opportunity to defend itself. It makes no sense if, for example, defenders and attackers fight for the ball in the small area and stand offside.

Offside contributes significantly to the dynamics of the game. The offside rule was part of the rules of football even before they were written. In 2009, it was established that a defender who leaves the field without the permission of the referee must be considered to stand at the nearest demarcation line to decide whether an attacker is in an offside position. [103] These are bold statements, especially without references. I could easily answer your second statement with “who?” (Offside rules reduce the entertainment value of the game. In 2005, the IFAB clarified that when assessing the position of an attacking player under the offside law, the part of the player`s head, body or feet closest to the goal line of the defending team must be taken into account, excluding the hands and arms. For “no advantage can be obtained: if only the arms are in front of the adversary”. [101] In 2016, it was clarified that this principle should apply to all players, forwards and defenders, including the goalkeeper. [102] It wasn`t until 2018 that FIFA began giving World Cup officials the opportunity to review video recordings to confirm calls. This year, the company is introducing new semi-automatic offside technology to improve its video assistant refereeing (VAR) system at the 2022 World Cup in Qatar.

Modern offside law remains unknown, but it has created a climate in which some of the finest football matches of all time have been produced. Offside in football is a rule that prevents players from standing near the opponent`s goal. A player becomes offside if he is on the opposite side of the field and the player does not have the ball or there are two players from the other team between him and the goal. Three became two in the early 1900s because they wanted to increase the score in games. With three defenders needed in front of an attacker to hold a sideways position, it was almost impossible to pass a ball through the defense forward to put a player in one-on-one with a goal. If one run hit one defender, the other could wipe himself before the goalkeeper needed to be alarmed. There is no such safety net with a two-defender version of the offside bill, and the score increased by 35% in the year of passing. Another change was recently made to allow offensive players to start from a parallel position to the last defender, another step that should shift the balance in favor of the offense. While it seems unlikely that any further changes will be made in the near future, there are always experiments of one kind or another, and I wouldn`t be too surprised if the offside rule was applied to be introduced fairly quickly (see below). Rugby football has handled the situation by banning any forward passing. Sheffield completely ignored him for a while.

A number of other schools had some sort of football offside rule. Interestingly, the division between rugby and football began before the ban on ball handling in association football, although there are already cultural differences as to whether the game was played primarily with hands or feet. Eton loved to dribble, Marlborough the catch-and-run. However, there was no concrete set of rules that made competitions between schools problematic. This came to a head after young men in public schools became students at British universities, where games became a farce in which everyone played by the rules they had been taught. In Cambridge, after several fights broke out over controversial football matches, a number of students who had played for different schools finally codified a series of compromise laws for their football club. The Cambridge Rules became the first piece of legislation of the national football association.